 |
"Experience Social Investing
...Without Taking Risk"
*Earning Financial, Social and Environmental Dividends
42 Pensions, Foundations, Endowments, Others
Gather to "Test Drive" About SRI
NEW YORK, N.Y.///June 10, 2002/// More than 40 treasurers from leading
U.S. pension funds, foundations and religious
organizations met for the second annual Triple Bottom
Line Simulation - a unique investment model allowing
them at make socially responsible investments (SRI)
across five key asset classes in a virtual setting.
This year's conference sponsored by Capital Missions
at New York's Roosevelt Hotel brings together treasurers
from organizations such as the MacArthur Foundation, the
General Board of Pensions of the United Methodist
Church, Amnesty International, Rockefeller Foundation,
National Wildlife Fund, Cambridge Associates, Stanford
Management Company, the Service Employees International
Union (SEIU) and many others.
"Capital Missions
is delighted to report that more than 40 treasurers were
able to join us at this year's events. Thanks to a great
deal of dialogue, many of the attendees learned a great
bit. Many participants can now see that a totally
responsibly invested portfolio pays off in many ways -
both in financial terms and social and environmental
terms. Also the financial officers have created a
'Simulation Network' organization to guide the
Simulation going forward."
In May 2001,
treasurers met in New York City to create five
Simulations of $100 million. The inaugural program was
open by invitation only to pension funds, foundation
treasurers, religious treasurers, endowments and
families. Quarterly reports of the Simulations allow
treasurers to compare the "mock" results with the
results achieved by their actual money managers. The
first quarter 2002 Triple Bottom Line Simulation results
compared to their financial benchmarks are shown below.
Social Screening simulation: -0.71 percent
Shareholder Activism simulation: 0.54 percent
Community Development simulation: 0.01 percent
Social Venture Capital simulation: 1.09 percent
General SRI simulation: -1.88 percent
Davis said: "The Simulations are closely tracking or
outperforming their benchmarks. It is important to
recognize that these comparisons are to appropriate
financial benchmarks, not gross return numbers. It is
also important to note that no value is attached to the
social and environmental positives attached to the
social investment products.”
The five simulations developed by the treasurers have specific social change criteria include:
- Social Screening Simulation. Generally, socially responsible investors
seek to own profitable companies that make positive contributions to
society. Screening is the practice of including or excluding companies from
portfolios based on social and/or environmental criteria. These criteria can
range from the diversity of a company's board of directors, to the impact of
company operations on the environment, or to the percentage of company
revenues received from weapons contracting, gambling, liquor or tobacco. The
qualitative research and evaluation process known as screening generally
seeks to first eliminate the worst of the worst (avoidance) and then, from
the large universe of possibilities that remains, identify the best
companies in various industry classifications. Negative/avoidance screening
yields a social dividend of withholding capital from firms with poor social
and environmental performance. Positive social screening yields a dividend
of supporting companies that are doing better than most on social and
environmental matters.
- Shareholder Advocacy Simulation. Shareholder advocacy describes the
actions many socially aware investors take in their role as responsible
owners of corporate America. These efforts include dialoguing with companies
on issues of concern, and submitting and voting proxy resolutions. Advocacy
efforts are aimed at positively influencing corporate behavior. Social
investors generally target the social issues most important to achieving
their organization's mission and often work cooperatively to steer
management on a course that is believed will improve financial performance
over time and enhance the well being of all the company's stakeholders -
customers, employees, vendors and communities, as well as stockholders.
Management teams who embrace the stakeholder concept of management are
viewed as more enlightened, exhibiting the progressive attitudes of business
leaders of the future, and likely to outperform their competitors over time.
Shareholder advocacy can lead to better corporate performance on social or
environmental issues, an important social dividend.
- Community Investment Simulation. Social dividends are achieved in this
area by doing business with community development financial institutions
(banks, credit unions, venture capital firms and other community-focused
entities) for cash equivalent products such as banking accounts and jumbo
certificates of deposit. The Social Investment Forum, the industry trade
group, advocates that social investors target one percent of their
investment portfolios to local community initiatives through reputable
CDFIs. Social dividends from community investment include increased
affordable housing, job creation and a wider availability of high quality
childcare in low-income and underserved communities.
- Social Venture Capital simulation. Some of the most powerful solutions
to social problems come from start-up companies. Sectors that have seen
innovative products include alternative energy, organic food, affordable
housing, development banking and electric cars. Institutional investors are
increasingly seeking benefits for society as well as venture industry
financial returns by investing in these "social ventures."
- General SRI Simulation. This simulation is a blend of the four other
simulations.
The socially responsible funds and investment
alternatives employed by the Triple Bottom Line
Simulation include: Calvert Social Investment Fund
(Equity Portfolio), Domini Institutional Social Equity
Fund, Rockefeller & Co. Libra Fund, Walden Asset
Management (Innovations Portfolio), Roxbury Capital
Management SR Large Cap Core Growth Fund, State Street
Global Advisors SR Equity Strategy Fund, Calvert Social
Investment Fund (Bond Portfolio), Freddie Mac CMO
Sequential, Freddie Mac MBS Pass Through, Pax World High
Yield Fund, State Street Global Advisors SR Intermediate
Bond Strategy, Calvert Foundation Community Investment
Notes, Green Cay Asset Management Siebels Emerging
Market Tech Fund, Solstice Fund II and ShoreBank SRI
Jumbo CD.
The 12-year-old Capital Missions Company has created
10 networks of social investors in 10 years, including
venture capital investors, financiers of America's
leading African-American companies, financiers of
premiere women-led businesses, companies offering social
investment products, solar investors and
micro-enterprise investors.
Capital Missions
Company has created a proprietary process to launch
social investor networks: KINS, the Key Initiator
Network Strategy. KINS targets a particular niche of
finance, sets an inspiring goal, identifies the
constituencies within the niche, identifies the key
influencers within each constituency and invites the key
influencers to design and launch the network. CMC's fees
come from consulting on network formation and network
growth.
Capital Missions' Founder and CEO is
Susan Davis. Over the past 30 years, she has helped
start five respected socially-responsible companies
including South Shore Bank, the nation's first
neighborhood development bank. Including her nine years
as a division administrator in the Personal Trust Group
of Chicago’s Harris Bank, Ms. Davis has spent 29 years
in various sectors of finance.
Please note that the links below have been
disabled due to the time lapse.
Below are the summary of the first quarter 2002 returns of the Triple Bottom Line Simulation, showing that three of five "Social Investment Simulations" beat their benchmarks in the first year.
Executive Summary (PDF; 7K)
Asset Allocation and Return Summary (PDF; 12K)
Community Development Simulation (PDF; 9K)
Shareholder Activism Simulation (PDF; 9K)
Social Screening Simulation (PDF; 9K)
Social Venture Capital Simulation (PDF; 9K)
General SRI Portfolio Simulation (PDF; 9K)
For more details click here.
|
 |